In 2019, Deputy Winch fell asleep at the wheel while returning to the station after his overnight shift. His vehicle crossed the double yellow line, colliding head-on with a car driven by Susan Harrington, who was killed instantly. The Attorney General’s Office declined to press charges, stating that the failure to perceive a risk does […]
Officer Maggio conducted canine searches that were perceived as racially motivated by fellow officers. Complaints were made alleging that these searches targeted black officers. Specific dates and outcomes of these complaints are not detailed in the available records. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Officer Maggio](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/officer-maggio/)
Officer Divorl engaged in inappropriate sexual comments and behavior towards a female colleague, including making explicit remarks while using a massaging chair. The incident was reported, and a meeting was held with supervisors. The female officer felt intimidated during the meeting and signed a letter indicating the matter was resolved. No further disciplinary actions were […]
Officer Legg referred to a fellow officer as a ‘Blaxican,’ referencing the officer’s black and Latino background. The officer complained to supervisors about this, but it is unclear whether any reprimand or disciplinary action was taken. Specific dates are not provided in the available records. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Officer John Legg](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/officer-john-legg/)
Officer Brooks was reported to have used the ‘n-word’ and made other racially charged comments about black officers. After complaints were made, he ceased making these comments. Specific dates and disciplinary actions are not detailed in the available records. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Officer Brooks](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/officer-brooks/)
In 2015, Sergeant Polacco used the term ‘colored girl’ to refer to a colleague. This incident was investigated, and he was subsequently counseled. No further disciplinary actions were noted in the available records. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Sergeant Polacco](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/sergeant-polacco/)
Investigated in 2013 for ‘recycling time,’ a practice where he submitted time cards indicating he worked on days he did not, leading to overpayment. An arbitration in 2015 found him guilty of carelessness and negligence in recording time, resulting in a two-week unpaid suspension. Spencer did not lose his job or benefits but faced scrutiny […]
Charged alongside Deputy Scott Walters in connection with a 2013 sexual assault case. Pinney reached a plea deal, pleading guilty to reckless endangerment and attempted forcible touching, resulting in one year of probation. His involvement in the case contributed to public concerns about misconduct within the department. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Deputy Matthew Pinney](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/deputy-matthew-pinney/)
Acquitted in 2019 of rape and sexual abuse charges stemming from a 2013 incident. Despite the acquittal, the case drew significant public attention and scrutiny towards the department’s handling of sexual assault allegations involving its officers. ## Officer Forum Links: – [Deputy Scott Walters](https://watchaudits.com/forums/topic/deputy-scott-walters/)
Found by a federal judge in March 2024 to have used excessive force during the wrongful arrest of Ronald Georgia in June 2019. Davenport responded to a noise complaint at Georgia’s residence, where he pushed Georgia twice, causing him to fall over a cooler, and arrested him without lawful justification. The court awarded Georgia $50,000 […]
Convicted of third-degree perjury in March 2023 for lying under oath during the 2019 rape trial of fellow deputy Scott Walters. Starner falsely testified about a conversation with a New York State Police Investigator regarding the existence of a video related to the case. He was placed on paid administrative leave in September 2019 and […]
In May 2021, Undersheriff Richard Hallett conducted an investigation into former Undersheriff Moulton’s alleged misconduct, including drinking on duty and mismanagement of funds. Hallett’s findings led to Moulton’s removal from the New York State Central Registry of Police and Peace Officers for incompetence or misconduct. This action was contested by Moulton, who claimed the allegations […]
In May 2023, the Appellate Division, Third Department, upheld the termination of Sergeant Gerald Minckler for multiple incidents of sexual harassment. Testimonies revealed that Minckler, while appearing intoxicated and armed, grabbed a female deputy’s breast, made inappropriate comments, and threatened her. Another deputy testified that Minckler made unwanted physical advances and sexually explicit remarks. Both […]
In September 2023, Detective Sergeant Austin Rowlands was accused of official misconduct and criminal mischief during the execution of a warrant in Angola. Allegations included using a bowie knife to damage a television, employing an axe to disable surveillance cameras, and striking a pickup truck with the axe. Rowlands resigned from his position in January […]
On March 1, 2020, Deputy Sheriff Merria, along with Officers Pryce, Sirles, and Shaver, allegedly used excessive force against Timothy Lalonde, a blind man, during an arrest. Lalonde suffered multiple injuries, including brain damage, a broken left wrist, and a torn rotator cuff. A lawsuit was filed against Merria and others, alleging violations of Lalonde’s […]
