The Elizabeth Police Department has faced multiple lawsuits and allegations of misconduct over the past decade. Notably, in April 2023, the city settled a false arrest lawsuit for $99,500 involving officers Jorge Hidalgo, Vincent Flatley, and Grisel Arias, who arrested a man in diabetic shock under suspicion of DUI. Additionally, in September 2023, Officer Alfonso Colon faced ongoing litigation for allegedly providing false statements leading to an unlawful indictment. These incidents highlight concerns regarding the department’s handling of medical emergencies and the accuracy of criminal charges.