NYPD Officer arrested in Sept. 2019 for menacing during an off-duty road rage incident in Queens, where he allegedly pulled a gun on two people and threatened to “shoot and murder” them. An NYPD internal review found him guilty of displaying his firearm and of menacing, harassment, and unauthorized off-duty work; he was docked vacation days and put on dismissal probation for one year. In criminal court, Case pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct (a non-criminal violation), resulting in his case being sealed. He kept his job and returned to full duty at the 79th Precinct with his service weapon; the victims of the incident have filed a civil lawsuit against him, which is ongoing.